2005
Closer to You
Debut album track; tender and intimate
2005
Fall Apart Again
Written by the Hanseroth twins; emotional standout from debut
2005
Fall Apart Again (Single)
Single release from debut album era
2005
Follow
Opening track of debut album; showcases her raw folk-rock power from the start
2005
Gone
Debut album track; co-written with Phil and Tim Hanseroth
2005
Hallelujah (Live at KCRW)
Early live single released via KCRW; the recording that first brought her to wider attention
2005
Happy
Solo-written debut album track; deceptively simple
2005
In My Own Eyes
Solo-written debut track; introspective
2005
Someday Never Comes
Debut album track; co-written with Tim Hanseroth
2005
Throw It All Away
Re-recorded for the 2006 Columbia re-release; fan favourite from debut era
2005
Tragedy
Closing track of debut album; dramatic solo-written closer
2005
What Can I Say
Early single; bright and melodic; featured on Rolling Stone's 10 Artists to Watch in 2005
2006
What Can I Say (Single)
Single from debut album; 2006 Columbia re-release
2007
Again Today
Track 13 of The Story; Pearl Jam covered it on Cover Stories (2017); segues into the hidden track after 2+ minutes of silence
2007
Cannonball
Album track featuring Indigo Girls; later covered by Indigo Girls on Cover Stories
2007
Downpour
Album track; later covered by Margo Price on Cover Stories
2007
Have You Ever
Hanseroth-written fan favourite from The Story; later covered by The Avett Brothers on Cover Stories
2007
Hiding My Heart
Hidden track on The Story following Again Today; written by Tim Hanseroth; T Bone Burnett did not love it so it ended up buried; Adele covered it as a bonus track on her album 21 which became the original inspiration for the entire Cover Stories tribute album
2007
Josephine
Album track; later covered by Anderson East featuring Miranda Lambert on Cover Stories
2007
Late Morning Lullaby
Opening track of The Story; co-written with the Hanseroths; later covered by Shovels and Rope on Cover Stories
2007
Losing Heart
Album track; later covered by The Secret Sisters on Cover Stories
2007
My Song
Album track on The Story; later covered by Old Crow Medicine Show on Cover Stories
2007
Shadow on the Wall
Closing track of The Story; later covered by Ruby Amanfu on Cover Stories
2007
The Story
Breakthrough single; US #75; used in GM Olympics commercials driving a 368% sales spike; famous for the vocal crack in the title track; T Bone Burnett production